Strategy

Amazon FBA or dropshipping: which strategy should you choose?

By the SellerPerformance team · Published · 4 min read

Both models spare you from handling shipping, but they do not carry the same risks.

Key takeaways

  • Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) requires you to buy inventory and send it in.
  • Dropshipping is tightly regulated by Amazon’s policies.
  • In both cases, you remain responsible for the product sold.

What is the difference between Fulfillment by Amazon and dropshipping?

In both cases you do not pack orders yourself, but the inventory is not in the same place. With Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), you buy your inventory and send it to Amazon’s fulfillment centers, which store, pack, ship, and handle part of customer service. With dropshipping, you hold no inventory: when a customer orders, you pass the order to a supplier that ships directly to the customer.

The two models are often presented as equivalent ways to sell “without logistics.” Yet they do not involve the same capital, the same control, or the same risks for your account.

Comparing the two models
CriterionFulfillment by AmazonDropshipping
InventoryBought in advance and sent to AmazonHeld by the supplier
Starting capitalHigherLower
Control over delivery timesHandled by AmazonDepends on the supplier
Quality controlPossible before shipping inventory inLimited, product rarely seen
Amazon’s frameworkOfficial program, inbound and storage rulesAllowed under strict conditions
Responsibility to the customerYoursYours

What does Fulfillment by Amazon require?

Fulfillment by Amazon requires you to buy inventory and send it into Amazon’s fulfillment network. You pay for products before selling them, then fulfillment fees and storage fees, which rise if inventory sits in the warehouse for a long time.

In return, Amazon picks, packs, and delivers orders, which makes your offers Prime-eligible and helps you meet delivery times. Your work focuses on sourcing, quality, listings, and managing inventory levels.

The main points to watch:

  • Cash needs: inventory is paid for long before it sells.
  • Overstock risk: a slow-selling product generates storage fees and may have to be removed or liquidated.
  • Stockout risk: restocking too late costs sales and ranking.
  • Prep requirements: Amazon’s own labeling, packaging, and inbound rules.

To compare Fulfillment by Amazon with shipping orders yourself, read our article Fulfillment by Amazon or by the seller.

Is dropshipping allowed on Amazon?

Yes, but it is tightly regulated by Amazon’s policy. Dropshipping is accepted only if you clearly remain the seller of the order in the customer’s eyes. Broadly, Amazon’s drop shipping policy requires that:

  • you are identified as the seller of record on packing slips, invoices, external packaging, and other information included with the order;
  • any information identifying another seller or supplier is removed before shipping;
  • you remain responsible for accepting and processing customer returns;
  • you comply with all other seller rules.

The policy specifically prohibits buying products from another online retailer and having that retailer ship directly to customers when the shipment does not identify you as the seller of record. Failing to follow the policy can lead to account suspension. Check the current version of the policy in Seller Central Help before you start.

What risks does dropshipping pose to your account?

The main risk is losing control over what drives your metrics. Amazon judges your account on shipping times, cancellations, late deliveries, claims, and product authenticity. With dropshipping, these depend on a supplier you do not directly control.

  1. Unreported stockouts: the supplier is out of the product and you must cancel the order.
  2. Long delivery times, especially when the supplier ships from far away, which hurt your delivery metrics.
  3. No usable invoices: if there is an authenticity complaint, Amazon may ask for supplier invoices that dropshipping does not always provide.
  4. Unknown quality of a product you have never handled.
  5. Non-compliant parcels that mention the supplier or another website.

If you consider this model, choose an established supplier able to issue invoices in your name, ship under your identity, and guarantee delivery times compatible with Amazon’s.

How do you choose between the two models?

In both cases, you remain responsible for the product sold: its compliance, safety, authenticity, and after-sales service. The choice therefore depends less on logistics than on your ability to handle these responsibilities.

  • Fulfillment by Amazon fits if you can finance inventory, have identified products that sell steadily, and want reliable delivery times.
  • Dropshipping can fit for testing a product or for bulky or very specific items, provided you have a reliable supplier and follow Amazon’s policy strictly.

Either way, calculate your margin with every fee before committing. Our article on Amazon fees helps you run the numbers. To learn the basics of the seller’s job, our Seller Academy offers training.

Frequently asked questions

Can you combine both models?

Yes. Some sellers put their steadiest products in Fulfillment by Amazon and ship, or have shipped, their rarer products themselves. Each order must then follow the rules of the method used.

Is dropshipping from a consumer retail site allowed?

No, if the parcel does not identify the Amazon seller as the seller of record. Buying from another online retailer to have the customer delivered directly is expressly targeted by Amazon’s policy.

Who is responsible if a product is defective?

You are, as the seller, toward the customer and Amazon. You can then turn to your supplier under your contract.

Read next

A question about your account?

Let’s talk about your marketplace business.

Describe your situation in a few lines and we will come back to you with a first opinion.