Profitability

Amazon customer reviews: what is allowed and what is not

By the SellerPerformance team · Published · 5 min read

Reviews weigh on sales, and Amazon penalizes review manipulation heavily.

Key takeaways

  • Never offer anything in exchange for a review.
  • Use the review request feature the platform provides.
  • Respond to reported problems by fixing the product or the listing.

Why do customer reviews matter so much on Amazon?

Reviews matter because they are often the last thing a shopper checks before clicking "Add to Cart." The average star rating appears in search results, right next to the price and the main image. A well-rated listing reassures shoppers; a listing with few reviews, or with recent negative ones, slows down the decision.

Reviews are also a source of information for you. They tell you what shoppers understand about your product, what they expected, and what disappointed them. A seller who reads reviews every week spots a defect, an unclear manual, or a misleading photo much earlier.

Precisely because reviews influence sales, Amazon watches their authenticity closely. The platform considers that a review must reflect a customer's real, unprompted experience. Any attempt to steer or buy that opinion is treated as manipulation.

What does Amazon prohibit when it comes to reviews?

Amazon prohibits any action that distorts reviews, whether it comes from you, your family, your employees, or a service provider acting on your behalf. The principle is simple: you cannot buy a review, steer it, or write it yourself.

These are the practices to avoid, even when they look harmless:

  • offering anything in exchange for a review: a refund, a free product, a discount code, a gift, a gift card, or an entry into a giveaway;
  • asking only for positive reviews, or contacting only the customers you believe are satisfied;
  • adding a package insert that ties a benefit to posting a review;
  • writing, or having others write, reviews of your own products, whether by you, your relatives, your staff, or friends;
  • posting negative reviews on a competitor's products;
  • asking a customer to change or remove a review, especially in exchange for a refund;
  • using groups, websites, or services that trade reviews or promise ratings.

Outsourcing this activity does not protect you. If a provider manipulates reviews for your products, your account is the one at risk.

The consequences can be serious: removal of the affected reviews, removal of the listing, and even suspension of the seller account. If your account has already been hit, our article on the first things to do after a suspension will help you avoid making matters worse.

How can you get reviews without breaking the rules?

The safe method is to use the tools Amazon provides and to take care of the customer experience. There is no approved shortcut.

The Request a Review button in Seller Central

Seller Central offers a "Request a Review" button on each order's details page. Amazon then sends the customer a standardized message inviting them to rate both the product and the seller. Amazon writes the text, which removes any risk of biased wording on your side. The button can only be used during a set period after delivery; Seller Central shows you whether a request is still possible.

The platform's official programs

Depending on your situation, especially if your brand is enrolled in Brand Registry, Amazon may give you access to programs designed to collect early reviews on new products. Terms and costs change over time, so check them directly in Seller Central before you commit.

Messages to customers

If you write to a customer yourself through Buyer-Seller Messaging, stay neutral. You can ask for their opinion, but do not suggest a rating, do not promise anything, and do not first ask whether they are happy. When in doubt, use the official button.

What should you do about a negative review?

The right response to a negative review is to deal with its cause, not with the review itself. A well-founded critical review is valuable information, and it usually costs you nothing.

Here is a simple process:

  1. Read the whole review and identify the specific issue: a defect, sizing, the manual, packaging, delivery time, or a gap between the product and the photo.
  2. Check whether the issue shows up in other reviews or in returns. A one-off case does not call for the same response as a recurring problem.
  3. Fix what you can: the listing if it creates a false expectation, the product or its packaging if the defect is real, your logistics if parcels arrive damaged.
  4. If the review breaks Amazon's Community Guidelines (abusive language, content unrelated to the product, personal information), report it through the channels Amazon provides.
  5. Monitor the next reviews to confirm that your fix worked.

What not to do: contact the customer to offer a refund in exchange for removing the review, or dispute every negative review by default. Both practices fall under manipulation.

Often, the fastest fix is in the listing itself. Incorrect dimensions or a misleading photo lead to disappointed reviews. Our article on the title, bullet points, and images of a product listing details what to check.

How do you build reviews into your regular monitoring?

Reviews belong in your routine, just like sales and margins. Regular monitoring lets you act before a problem drags your average rating down.

Regular review checkpoints
FrequencyWhat to checkPossible action
WeeklyNew 1- to 3-star reviewsIdentify and log the cause
MonthlyRecurring themes in reviews and returnsFix the listing or the product
At each launchFirst reviews on a new productConfirm the listing matches real-world use
OngoingYour service providers' practicesMake sure none of them requests reviews in exchange for a benefit

If you work with a team or with outside providers, put the rule in writing: no reviews in exchange for anything, no selective requests. If you want an outside view of your account's overall health, our Seller Performance service includes this kind of review.

Frequently asked questions

Can I offer a discount on a future order to a customer who leaves a review?

No. Any benefit tied to a review, even a small or delayed one, counts as a prohibited incentive.

Can I ask a satisfied customer to leave a review?

You can ask for a review in neutral terms, without steering the rating. Do not filter customers based on how satisfied you think they are; the simplest option is the Request a Review button in Seller Central.

Can Amazon remove an unfair negative review?

Amazon can remove a review that breaks its Community Guidelines. A negative review that describes a real experience stays up, and the useful response is to fix the underlying cause.

Read next

A question about your account?

Let’s talk about your marketplace business.

Describe your situation in a few lines and we will come back to you with a first opinion.